Under-Age and Over-Done?

by , under Dermal Fillers, News, Plastic Surgery, Smart Lipo MPX

Heidi Montag’s plastic surgery procedures are getting a lot of publicity this week. It raises questions that all patients and professionals must answer:

1. What age is the “right age” to begin aesthetic procedures?
We at FUZION opt to reserve the right to refuse treatment to any person who is not physically or emotionally mature. It is not necessarily about a specific age, but it is preferred to operate on legally consenting patients who are physically mature. If a professional chooses to operate/perform an aesthetic procedure on a minor they must consider how that procedure will impact growth or future physical outcome. We have already established in previous blogs that there are plenty of teenagers who have moderate facial wrinkles. This is caused by excessive photodamage (tanning) or pure genetics. The most popular adolescent cosmetic surgery is rhinoplasty (“nosejob”), now I ask you, would you make your child suffer the taunting of other kids until they are 18?

2. Is the patient in front of you psychologically sound to undergo the proposed procedure(s)?
Each Board Certified Plastic Surgeon/ medical professional (like me, I’m a Certified Physician Assistant) is fully trained in psychologic evaluation. It is important to seek out medical professionals for your aesthetic procedure. During a consultation each patient is physically and psychologically evaluated. We screen for conditions including body dysmorphic disorder, anorexia, psychotic illness, histrionic or other personality disorders. If a prospective patient displays signs of these, or a number of other diseases, they will be referred to a mental health professional. Dr. Goodkind and I have many professional relationships with excellent mental health providers. It is never to be taken as a sign of disrespect if you are referred, it just means that we are concerned enough to take care of you. Remember, “DO NO HARM!”

3. Is the patient aware of the risks?
The risks of ALL procedures are thoroughly discussed as part of the informed consent process. If the patient doesn’t verbally express understanding the plan is thwarted. It is a huge responsibility, and a goal of ours at FUZION, to make sure that you, as the patient, are fully educated and understand all aspects of each procedure.

4. Do the desired effects outweigh the risk?
Example: if a patient asks for extraordinarily large breast implants, but we know that they will be too large for her small frame then she will be risking infection, delayed healing, increased risk of rupture, chronic pain and muscle imbalance of her chest wall. These risks outweigh the benefits and therefore would not be appropriate. We don’t like to trade one problem for another.

5. What are the longterm implications of these procedures?
We need to evaluate what these procedures mean for a patient’s future – example: when silicone  is injected into someone’s face it is permanent. As that person ages, the silicone may not appear natural – it does not age as they do and therefore makes them look unnatural. We see plenty of examples of this in Hollywood, New York and Miami. It may be a desirable look to start, but it may not end up that way.

6. What is the patient’s motivation?
During the consultation a patient’s motivation must be clearly established. Why are they seeking surgical or aesthetic procedures? Are they doing it for someone else?  To save a relationship? To “cure” depression?  These are all examples of poor motivation and would be deemed inappropriate candidates for surgery.

7. What are the patient’s expectations and are they realistic?
To achieve a natural look and excellent results, one must have realistic expectations. Aesthetics is ALL ABOUT setting realistic expectations. I encounter this everyday. Dermal fillers, in the right hands, can provide amazing non-surgical results, but the results are subtle and certainly NOT surgical results. It is about technique, skill of the injector, choosing the appropriate product and of course the right patient. I often times have to disappoint people by telling them that they are more apporpriate surgical candidates than filler candidates. This is a perfect example of why people look unnatural: the wrong amount of the wrong product in the wrong patient… (Mickey RourkeMeg Ryan, “Cat Lady“)

8. When is enough enough?
If your Aesthetic Professional tells you that you need to lay off procedures, or that the procedure will give you an unnatural appearance you need to stop! Or seek mental health assistance if you have become obsessive. No professional should risk their reputation, and future in the field for one bad outcome that could have been avoided. This is the sole reason that I refuse to give people “DUCK LIPS!” Subtle is always more attractive and believeable. You want to be yourself, just more detailed.

Who is to say that Heidi went too far?  Her surgeon was a Professional Board Certified Plastic Surgeon, who has a stellar reputation (Dr. Frank Ryan). She thought about the procedures for three years prior to going ahead with them. Dr. Ryan performed multiple consultations about her procedures and states that she thoroughly and repeatedly expressed understanding her risks. Just because we may not agree with her decision to seek a significantly more mature, and augmented appearance does not mean that it was unethical on the part of the practitioner. All in all, on a professional level his work was impressively done – much more natural than some other examples. We must consider that if Ms. Montag had chosen to have one procedure at a time we would think nothing of this, but since she had multiple minor procedures (fat transfers and BOTOX) at the same time she had multiple surgeries it has been  sensationalized in the media. Don’t forget who we are talking about, “reality star”, Playboy model (to come), aspiring singer and 1/2 of the ”Speidi” duo… It all has to be taken with a grain of salt – a very big grain of salt.

Tell me what you think! I would love to hear what you have to say about all of this.



  1. Erica says:

    I guess I live under a rock because I hadn’t heard about Heidi…I happen to think she looked good before and now after. Did she need it? Well she looks really good now so I guess it didn’t hurt. It did probably hurt…all that in one day-pretty intrusive on one’s body. Fuzion introduced me to the benefits of accentuating the postitives. People didn’t know that I had had fillers, botox, peels, latisse, teeth whitening, smart lipo…they just NOTICED that I looked good, confident, well rested, and bright complexion…hmmmmm is that so bad? Congratulations Heidi, you look amazing!

  2. Lynne Bohan says:

    I hope your timely and extremely informative blog will be read and absorbed by anyone, regardless of age, considering cosmetic surgery or any other form of cosmetic alteration. Heidi Montag is a perfect example of a young woman who knows that she’s not beautiful and will probably never be considered so — especially by the Holloywood-watching public and her more perfectly formed peers. In addition, no matter what she has done to her face and/or body, Heidi’s looks are overshadowed by her extremely unattractive, cold-as-ice personality and her over-the-top attention seeking antics. Granted, her “10-Procedures” headlines have given her those precious “15 minutes of fame,” but I’m sure the Heidi Montag surgery soap opera will soon be cancelled and removed from the airwaves.